Touchscreen MacBook Pro: Has Apple Lost Its Way?

4 min read
Touchscreen MacBook Pro: Has Apple Lost Its Way?
🤖 AI-generated summary
  • The new MacBook Pro switches to tandem OLED, loses weight, and gets a touchscreen. 👆
  • Under the hood, nothing changes: still M5 Pro and M5 Max chips, no M6 or M5 Ultra.
  • The touchscreen remains a nice gimmick. The display and weight are the real upgrades.

Apple did it. After fifteen years of explaining that a vertical screen wasn’t meant for fingers, the MacBook Pro gets a touchscreen.

Everyone was waiting for the ultimate MacBook (Ultra). Instead, we got a MacBook you can poke at.

An OLED screen that changes everything

The real star is the display panel. Apple switches to tandem OLED, the same tech as on the iPad Pro. Advertised 10-million-to-1 contrast ratio, truly black blacks, and virtually no blooming around bright elements on dark backgrounds.

You have the choice between a glossy finish and the matte nano-texture version for a few extra 🤑. I recommend the option, especially on a laptop.

The bezels are thinner, giving you a bit more display area for the same chassis. The bottom corners of the screen are now rounded, just like the top corners.

Lighter, and you can feel it

Thanks to OLED and a redesigned cooling system, the MacBook Pro slims down. The 14-inch drops to 1.38 kg. The 16-inch goes down to 1.82 kg, compared to 2.14 kg for the old one.

On a 16-inch, losing over 300 grams is the difference between “I’m taking it with me” and “I’m leaving it on the desk.” I have a MacBook Pro 16 , so I know what I’m talking about: it’s a great machine, but I admit I don’t feel like pulling it out on a train or on the go because it’s so bulky.

The glowing Apple logo is back on the lid. Those nostalgic for the 2010 aluminum MacBook will shed a tear. The question I ask myself is: why did they remove it in the first place?

Dynamic Island and the rest

The notch disappears in favor of a Dynamic Island. Inside, still the webcam and ambient light sensor. Still no Face ID, so we keep putting our finger on Touch ID like it’s 2016. Or incidentally, using an Apple Watch to unlock.

The speakers have been overhauled with more bass and better audio quality with the lid closed. But still not enough to DJ a party with just your MacBook.

As for the rest, nothing changes: same overall design, same ports, same keyboard, same battery life. The price starts at €3,299. For the entry-level model, obviously. So expect to pay €400 more than a standard MacBook Pro; I don’t think it’s highway robbery, but constantly pushing prices up these days—I’m not sure that’s the right strategy.

Touch, a demo rather than a revolution 👆

Apple adapted macOS: you can flick a window away like on an iPad, and small buttons expand under your finger so you don’t miss your target. But the system remains designed for the keyboard and trackpad.

The real issue is ergonomics. A vertical screen means holding your arm out in mid-air. After ten minutes, it feels like you’ve done a set of overhead presses.

No Apple Pencil support either. The most convincing use case remains testing iOS apps in the Xcode simulator with your finger, according to Apple. Personally, I’m not convinced. For testing, nothing beats an actual iPhone or iPad.

To work on a touch surface with a keyboard, the iPad Pro with its Magic Keyboard has already been doing the job for years.

Apple seems to be losing its way

Here’s my problem with this release. Everyone was expecting the ultimate MacBook, the “Ultra.” An M6 Max chip, or at the very least an M5 Ultra in a laptop.

What did we get? A new screen, featherweight lightness, and performance identical to the previous generation. The same M5 Pro and M5 Max as in the models already on sale.

People ready to drop €16,000 on a maxed-out spec aren’t people who want to touch their screen. They are video editors, devs running local LLMs, people who count GPU cores and GB of unified memory. They aren’t going to upgrade their machine just to leave fingerprints on it.

Apple seems to want to offer multiple options rather than imposing a single vision of the Mac. Why not. But by constantly releasing new features alongside what the public is actually waiting for, we end up with a lineup where nobody knows what to buy anymore.

Should you buy it?

If your MacBook Pro is three or four years old and you haul it around every day, the OLED screen and saved weight are real selling points. As for touch, you’ll use it twice to show off to your coworkers, then forget about it.

If you’re waiting for raw power, hold onto your money. The M5 Ultra will eventually show up.

Apple released the best-looking MacBook in its history, not the most powerful.

Feel free to reach out if you want to let me know whether you plan on laying your fingers on it.

Got a reaction to this article?

Feel free to reach out if you'd like to react to this article.

Me soutenir