Table of contents
🤖
AI-generated summary
- EZ Run, my first iOS app, is on the App Store. It took four submissions and three rejections over two and a half weeks. 🏃
- Each rejection pointed to a different issue, even though most were visible from the very first review.
- For small personal apps, we need a real alternative to the App Store.
That’s it, I have an app on the App Store. It took eighteen days and three rejections to get here.
The app is called EZ Run . You describe your running workout in one sentence (“8 × 400 m, 1 min rest”), AI builds it with your paces, and it gets sent to your Apple Watch. Free, no account, no ads. Development took two days. Publishing took almost three weeks.
The timeline
- October 17: First submission. Review promised in 48 hours max, I’m feeling confident.
- October 19: Rejection. The listing subtitle contains “Apple Watch” (guideline 5.2.5, use of Apple trademarks).
- October 22: Rejection. The HealthKit feature is not clearly identified in the interface (guideline 2.5.1).
- October 28: Rejection. The welcome screen offers “Allow” and “Later” before requesting Health access, which is forbidden (5.1.1). And while they’re at it: the word “Free” on the screenshots, and the video preview displayed inside an iPhone frame.
- November 4: Accepted. 🎉
Each time, fixed on the same day, resubmitted, and then a few days of waiting to discover the next issue.
Why not all at once?
That’s what drives me crazy. The word “Free” was on the screenshots from October 17. The video preview had its iPhone frame from October 17. The welcome screen with its “Later” button too. None of that changed between submissions.
Three people (or the same one, I have no idea) looked at the app, and each found one thing. Not all the things: one thing. As if the rule was to stop at the first problem and send it back.
If they had sent me the full list on October 19, I would have fixed everything that afternoon and the app would have been live on the 21st. We’re talking about Apple, a company worth over 3 trillion that takes 15 to 30% on every in-app purchase. Their review process is not worthy of a company like that.
Slightly contradictory rules
The rejection over “Apple Watch” still makes me smile. The app does one single thing: send a workout to the Apple Watch. But I’m not allowed to write it. So it became “Intervals on your watch”. Which watch? I’ll let you guess. ⌚
The HealthKit rejection is in the same vein. The app only uses HealthKit to schedule the workout on the watch; it doesn’t read any health data. But you still have to display “Apple Health integration (HealthKit)” spelled out in settings, otherwise the tester doesn’t see what it’s for.
I’m not disputing that these rules exist. They protect users, which is good. What I take issue with is how they are applied: one by one, with several days of waiting between each, and above all, without asking too many questions.
We need an alternative App Store
On iPhone, publishing an app—even if it’s free, even if it’s just for you and three friends—costs €99 a year for a developer account, a full store page, screenshots in the right dimensions, a privacy policy, and the review. Without a paid account, an app installed from Xcode expires after seven days.
In Europe, the DMA opened the door to alternative app stores. Except that apps going through them still have to be notarized by Apple. The door is open, but Apple keeps the key.
I’ve already tested Setapp as an alternative to the App Store on Mac. On iPhone, I’d like a real equivalent: a place to publish a small personal app without spending three weeks on it. The security check, I understand. The editorial control over the subtitle, much less so.
Wrap-up
The app is live, it works, and I’m happy with it. But if I do a 1.0.1 (it’s already ready), I already know I’ll be crossing my fingers when hitting “Submit for Review”.
On the dev side, I built everything with Claude without knowing Swift. I write about that on mouret.pro .
Feel free to reach out if you want to share your thoughts on this post, or if you’ve already survived App Review.